Welcome Guest Search | Active Topics | Log In | Register

Ideas please on how to help DSD with gender disappointment
Raff Offline
#1 Posted : Saturday, 10 December 2011 10:19:58 AM(UTC)


Rank: Queen of the Quackery

Posts: 3,296
Location: Western Australia

So DSD is upset that we are having another girl and I guess I was a bit unprepared for her reaction because she is very very disappointed. She told me she wasn't happy.

I'm not offended (at first I was secretly a bit offended but I'm now just concerned about her emotions)

I think, just going by what I feel may be the underlying issue is that because she was born to a teen mum and she has been an only child for 9 years, then in the space of 2.5 years she will have 3 siblings (her mum is pregnant too).

With DD, she was so excited to find out she would have a sister and she told me later that she prayed for a sister. And fir the past 2 years she has had DD all to herself and hasn't had to share her with anyone. But now I'm having another girl I think she may feel a bit uncertain of the future, maybe a bit jealous because she will have to share DD with another sister.

Her mum doesn't know the sex of her baby and I said to DSD "mum might be having a boy, you don't know yet" but I think she might want her mum to have a girl (i think she wanted a sister from her mum and a brother from us, not the other way around - that way she can have two sisters without feeling like she has to "share" them with any other sisters)

I know she just needs to "deal with it" which is what DH says but she does need some emotional support to come to terms with it and I need some ideas.

I've thought of taking her shopping to buy her new sister a gift but I don't think she's ready yet so that's on the cards for later. Thought of getting her to think of names but we have already named the baby... any other ideas?

Thanks for letting me rack your brains!
♥ SAHM Mummy (28) ♥ FIFO Daddy (38) ♥



lmkk Offline
#2 Posted : Saturday, 10 December 2011 10:49:05 AM(UTC)


Rank: Lady of the Lake

Posts: 1,942
Location: Victoria

Maybe emphasize how important DSD is to DD1. Maybe sitting with DD1 and making a special card and giving a special present, and emphasize the importance of sisters - rather than focusing on the new one just yet.

You could maybe have a chat with her about your own sisters (do you have sister? if not, say why you always wanted one?) and say how important a role being a bigger sister is.

When Tilly asked me about sisters i told her that big sisters are for looking after little sisters, sharing secrets and i told her that sisters are the very best friends she will ever have - in 3yo language lol.

I would also ask her "advice" about different situations, so which sheets should we make the baby's cot in, which special outfit will be the first she wears. etc. So basically involve her in everything. If you feel baby kick say "QUICK come feel!!" or even say something like "Everytime you are around all i can feel are somersaults in my tummy! she must recognize your voice?" Maybe?

I have never been in your position but i hope you can find a solution.
It sounds like a tough one!
BekL&E Offline
#3 Posted : Saturday, 10 December 2011 11:04:08 AM(UTC)

Rank: Moderator

Posts: 18,436
Location: Central QLD

I went through this with DS1. His 6 year old thought processing I am sure is a lot less complicated then your DSD though and you have a more complex issue.

When we told DS1 he was going to have another brother his face dropped... then he asked in a really quiet voice how we can change it for another one!! He was actually really sad because he told anyone that would listen right up until the 20 weeks scan he wanted a sister. I felt a bit sorry for him.

Within about 48 hours of the news he was over it and now can't wait for his brother to come. My boys are already like peas in a pod so I know there wont be issues. DS just had 2 friends in his class with baby sisters and I think that is where it all stemmed from.

Maybe your DSD just needs some processing time too? DS still thinks that he will have a sister one day, which he wont because we are making permanent contraceptive decisions!! Smile I've told him this but he still asks. He'll get over it!!

Good luck tackling the issue. Smile Smile
Bek: 33
DH: (Rob) 32
Luca Adam: Natural birth in Jan 2006, 3.6kg & BF for 22 months!!
Elliot Robert: Emerg C/S in Dec 2008, 2.8kg & BF for 29 months!!
‎Isaac Benjamin: Emerg C/S in Dec 2011, 1.9kg (32+2) & BF for 5 mths + with early help from Mothers Milk Bank!!

Raff Offline
#4 Posted : Saturday, 10 December 2011 11:05:30 AM(UTC)


Rank: Queen of the Quackery

Posts: 3,296
Location: Western Australia

Thanks Kat great ideas I will use all of them!

And thanks Bek, we only found out on Wednesday so hopefully in a few more days she will have come to terms with it a little bit...
♥ SAHM Mummy (28) ♥ FIFO Daddy (38) ♥



perthjanmumo7 Offline
#5 Posted : Saturday, 10 December 2011 10:39:41 PM(UTC)


Rank: Queen of the Quackery

Posts: 2,739
Location: PERTH WA

That is hard.
Just thinking outside the box, could the reaction be because of what is happening at home with her mum? Lots of changes there and some uncertanity ( i know dsd mum) plus your home renovations you were staying with your fil.
Maybe she just needs too find her "place" in everything, at both houses, highschool is not far away.2 new sibblings in 20 weeks or so is a lot for her too tackle.
Maybe try do some extra school holiday things with her, get her too plan a day with you and dd,set a budget and she can work it out?
Take her baby shopping?
So maybe it is not the sex of bub but everything else as well but she is using that as an excuse or outlet?
you know where i am, ring or text ok xx


Users browsing this topic
Anonymous (Hidden)
Forum Jump  
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.

Powered by YAF | YAF © 2003-2010, Yet Another Forum.NET
This page was generated in 0.289 seconds.